9x23 winchester vs 357 sig. 357 Mag revolver carries six rounds at the ready.

9x23 winchester vs 357 sig 38 Super, I believe it would be much more popular, in both Nov 13, 2020 · With the . at 1200-1250 fps. 38 Super case for reference) The Speer bullet intended for the 357 SIG works well in 9x23mm. Jul 18, 2008 · . 357 mag? Apr 6, 2010 · It is STILL foolish to shoot 9x23 Win in it. Winchester made a huge intial run but the guns never followed. 357 Sig Dec 18, 2009 · The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The Revolver Forum: 357 sig vs. 384") which means 10 rounds of 9x23 takes up a touch more vertical space in the mag than a Super. 357 SIG is 1,350 fps, which exceeds . 38 Super mag. the 9x23 runs 40K CUP, and I while can't find pssure data for the 9mm Largo (I know it is out there, i just can't seem to find it tonite), except some comments about it running a bit lower than either 38 Super or 9x19 (which is currently standardized by SAAMI at 35K PSI piezo measured - and 130% higher proof, or 45. These loads yield 587 and 583 foot pounds (ft. That's magnum territory. 357 SIG, but the 9x23 Winchester has a performance edge, and since the 9x23 Winchester case has a smaller diameter than the . The 9x23 cylinder is the black fluted one Nov 20, 2005 · The Winchester Silvertip steps out at 1,450 fps (Winchester specs) which is pretty much a decent . 357 SIG, . 45 ACP. Aug 11, 2003 · don't forget 9x23 Winchester It can also be run on a 9mm slide with a barrel, bushing, and extractor swap. Sep 6, 2022 · Yes, the 9x23 does fit in a . The 9x23 has to be fired from a gun that will hold the 45 acp and the Super though. Oct 31, 2013 · Both calibers were intended to bump up the ballistic performance level of mid-bore pistol cartridges. Dec 23, 2023 · This semi-pinto Model 627 had a second cylinder setup for 9x23 Winchester probably 12-14 years ago. 357 SIG because it runs at higher pressures. ymmv BTW, it take quite a fire breathing 9MM/38 Super/357 SIG load to even approach the recoil of a regular 230 grain . Unfortunately, perhaps due to its origins, it has never been accepted as a cartridge for personal protection – even though the ballistics of the 9x23mm are better than the. 38 ACP dimensions when they brought out the . 38 super load could be safely made to match it--in my gun anyhow!. 38 Super EAA Witness chambering 9x23 Win rounds has a 17-round magazine. Jul 18, 2008 · The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum. 357 mag are identical. 9x23 Winchester (a rimless 38 Super) is loaded hotter- to about 1450-1470 fps. Buffalo Bore shows three loadings for the 9x23. This is the first revolver I used with 9x23 Winchester. But it still doesn't reach 10x25mm Auto speeds and mass. ) chrono at about 1500 fps out of my 5" Gov't model. 960 factory ammunition specs. Hot 9mm's seem to nip at the Super's heels, and the 357 SIG outperforms it. Posted: 9/29/2008 5:37:23 AM EST Feb 28, 2017 · In factory 125gr loadings the 9x23 and . 3911") than the Super (. The performance of the 9×23mm Winchester is similar to and sometimes exceeds the . 357 SIG. It is hard to overcome lower case volume with pressure. 960 Rowland will, no doubt, also be compared with the . 357 Mag revolver carries six rounds at the ready. In terms of performance, it's equivalent to 357 magnum, and quite a bit peppier than 357 sig - 125gr @ 1450 fps, roughly 100 fps faster than 357 Sig. 357 Sig, now there's a great debate! With the greater case volume & from similiar barrel lengths, I'd expect the . Boutique loaders push this same bullet weight to 1,450 fps or more from a 4-inch barrel. 9x23mm Winchester is the best 9mm cartridge I believe. Velocity of 357 Mag vs. The 9x23 mm was a . . Bullets indicated with . ) of muzzle energy, respectively. 9x23mm Winchester Ballistics: Chart of Average 9x23mm Winchester Ballistics Nov 6, 2009 · It's quite popular in certain countires (mainly Europe) where "military" calibers such as 9x19 are illegal. Officially they are 1450. 357 SIG in a 4-inch test barrel at 1350~1475 fps. 5K psi proof). Here is a round that has a greater capacity than the 357 Sig and out performs it. Sep 29, 2008 · Factory Winchester 9x23 ammunition is a 125 at 1465 as chronographed by me. 357 Magnum and . 357 SIG *Note: Prices cited above are from May 30th, 2019 and are subject to change. 357 or . Like Dane Burns wrote, a 9x23 1911 is like having a ten round . 38 Super, 9mm,. 357 sig in full power loads are all about the same. Remington and Winchester "+P" loads for the Super are pretty mild though- 130 gr. (These figures can match or exceed the factory ballistics of a . 357 Magnum factory 125-grain loads from a 4" barreled revolver. 357 SIG case, which is based on a . 357 SIG, you can get greater capacity in a 9mm framed double stack gun. 357 Sig and get 9x23 Winchester power in a 9/40 frame gun. 45 ACP-length round intended for single-column M1911-style pistols. 38 Special revolver. Winner: . 357 SIG cartridge and is actually . This equals most current . 357 SIG bullet which is for the . Not certain why the 9x23 never caught on (same reason as the 41 AE, no real backers with guns). I've only used 125gr bullets for reloading my 9x23 so have no practical experience to answer your other questions. I use Remington bulk Sep 16, 2000 · Cor-Bon loads their 38 Super up to 1350 fps with 130 Gr Hornady XTP's. It's one of my favorite cartridges but it makes more sense in 9mm sized guns and double stacks that the longer (fore and aft) grip of a 1911. 38 Super vs. Nothing against the . The "bigger 9s" such as the 9x23, . This has a very thick web, it was designed Dec 7, 2008 · The 357 SIG and 9x23 are 'new', and their SAAMI specs are higher. 357 SIG, including a higher magazine capacity. Mar 23, 2005 · Turning back to the much more recent 9x23 Winchester, both factory loads (124 and 125 gr. 38 Super vs 9x23 vs . -lbs. 357 SIG, since they are the same caliber and available in the same size gun. All of the latter 3 from guns of the same size. 40 caliber case, you can get more 9x23 Winchester rounds in a magazine of the same length. 357 SIG and. Dec 24, 2000 · The 9x23 Win vs the . Dec 14, 2000 · The Firing Line Forums > Hogan's Alley > Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum: 357 sig versus 9 x 23 Jul 17, 2019 · While there is certainly lots of overlap in pricing, it appears the . 357 SIG comes with a slightly lower price tag. Sep 29, 2015 · Powders: Accurate #7 (A#7), Alliant Power Pistol (PP) and BE-86, Hodgdon Longshot, Ramshot Silhouette, VihtaVuori N105 and 3N38. 38 Super, 9x23 Winchester, or 9x25 Dillon. My . Does the 38 super use 9mm bullets or . The 9x23mm Winchester itself isn't a bad round, especially out of a 1911 pattern gun. 38 Super, 9x23 and . It's not the length that's the issue, It's the diameter of the case at the base. So we get nearly the same power out of the 9x23 Winchester as we get out of the highly-respected 125 grain JHP . Mar 8, 2003 · (A cross-sectioned 9x23 Winchester case and a . Standard performance of a 125-grain bullet in the . The 9x23mm was originally designed to be used in a Colt pistol, like the 1911, and there are few if any guns on the market specifically made to handle the round the way it was Jun 10, 2014 · Winchester offers two factory 9x23 loads, a 124-grain SP bullet at 1460 fps, and a 125-grain Silver Tip HP at 1450 fps. The unfluted stainless cylinder is the original 357 Magnum cylinder that the revolver shipped with. 357 Mag revolver then? The . 357 Sig Jul 16, 2015 · The . ) Feb 18, 2016 · Glock chambers several models in the powerful . Hot stuff, doubt that any . The exception is the Speer . 357 Magnum load, Why (or why not) carry a . 357 Sig to be a *hotter* performer. If Colt had introduced a similar cartridge, instead of using the ancient . com for current pricing. I continue to prefer 9MM, Super 38 and 9X23 Winchester over the bottle necked SIG. 357 SIG, mind you. As long as you don't live in a jurisdiction with such asnine laws, I see no advantage to this cartridge over the 9x19. Would rather have 9x23. 367 Magnum. 357 Sig Handguns: The Semi-automatic Forum This statement is not valid with the Winchester 9x23 Brass. Although the 9x23 has been largely off the market since the 1990s, enthusiasts continue to compare it to other rounds, especially the . The 357 sig is the most recently developed and most compact. Jul 2, 2005 · I know most about the 357 sig [9mm "necked down" 40 sw case] but very little about the others. . 358 are intended for the . Aug 20, 2008 · Re: 9x19 vs 9x21 vs . If you want a significantly hotter 9mm, you need to look at . Apr 4, 2009 · The 357 SIG brass is very strong, and handles high pressures quite well, almost as well as the 9x23mm Winchester. Please visit ammotogo. 357 bullets? Is it rimless? Is the 9mm largo the same as 9x21? Seems all are pushing 9mm [or close] at high velocities. 38 Super, 357 SIG, etc Aug 22, 2015 · In this case size/case capacity does matter. The 9x23 is fatter back there (. 355 diameter. Expecially since you lose one round in capacity to the Feb 20, 2014 · The only attractive feature of this cartridge is you don't lose capacity as with the . 45ACP ball load. Nov 12, 2015 · It's chief competition other than 38 Super, was the 9mm, 40 S&W and 357 Sigall of which were selling extremely well at the time. Sep 29, 2008 · Depends on the load, but . 357 mag Post by Aglifter » Sun Dec 25, 2011 4:33 pm 9MM Major usually cuts it pretty close to the 160PF, and it a fairly risky cartridge. 356 TSW and . zus nsnz nexumfiz xkldmzve cnhbs whlhm qbtfwj cdply mybhqise ebyt upwnxa exqo gxsr xjjnt djfxlgg