Camworks vs mastercam reddit with my current position running HSMworks, Fusion360, FeatureCAM and Powermill. GibbsCAM . Fusion 360 . Sort by: Best. With over 35 years of experience, the TriMech Group offers a comprehensive range of design, engineering, staffing and manufacturing solutions backed by experience and expertise that is unrivalled in the industry. Mastercam is probably one of the most used CAM systems in North America, primarily because they have the classes at a lot of the schools, whether it be trade schools or college, so, you're going to have far more job opportunities if you know MasterCam. Through out my career I have used Solidworks and AutoCAD for modeling. SolidCAM . Especially for 3 axis and turning. NX, from what I understand, is on a completely different level of cost and complexity. also a user friendly interface. Then they cracked down on some prominent pirates (mainly West Coast Choppers) and then a bunch of companies panicked and bought Mastercam licenses. Hsmworks for solidworks is a cheaper alternative I could probably get used to. When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that SolidWorks CAM is the preferred option. Back in the day everyone had a pirated copy of Mastercam. This sub-reddit is dedicated to everything related to BMW vehicles, tuning What do the different colors mean when doing cam? (Red/blue/green) is it fine if after my simulation a part of it is red? And should I aim for my product to be a particular color at the end ? Welcome to eMastercam. I learned on Esprit but they're definitely not springing for 5 seats of Esprit. I spent 5 years on Mcam and less than a year on camworks Most cam companies actually license the base strategies from the same supplier and the only real difference is how you interact with them. I did try Camworks and Solidcam and did not like them nearly as much. r/SolidWorks. Compare price, features, and reviews of the software side-by-side to make the best choice for your business. Esprit . Register now to participate in the forums, access the download area, buy Mastercam training materials, post processors and more. The videos are pretty good and give you the basics for mastercam. What do your parts look like? What are you making them on? Mastercam and Edgecam both seem very overwhelming with all of the menus and toolbars. SolidCAM vs CAMWorks. I don't know the software well enough to speak on it against mastercam. For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of Mastercam over SolidWorks CAM. Solidworks is primarily a design and engineering program, Mastercam is going to be the way to go if you are going into Machining. And because of the work I do, it's likely that that won't end anytime soon. Solid works CAM is a watered down version of camworks. I liked mastercam well enough when I was in school, mostly because the other software we had wanted to do everything for you, and wasn't very helpful when you wanted to specifically tweak something. The best reason to use Mastercam is because many shops primarily use Mastercam, and some will only use Mastercam. Try doing a 3-D surface with cam works. I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. I use solidworks exclusively to design my parts, assemblies, and do FEA & flow testing. Camworks has been around for a very long time. We have 30+ people running Mastercam. Best. Pretty sure Mastercam, camworks, Gibbs, hsmworks all have pretty much the same strategies. HSM (18) 4. When I needed CAM software, I chose CAMWorks, and was very happy with it for a number of years. That’s pretty much my work. CAMWorks vs SolidCAM. My wife recently got into making these large wooden letters so I have been using SolidWorks and CamWorks nesting to layout and cut pieces out of 4x4 sheets of plywood on my 50"x50" router. (The training still works for most mastercam versions just a little different, same execution though. You can program from sketches, solids, surfaces, or any combination. More posts you may like r/SolidWorks. The latter reason is why I'm learning Mastercam right now. . 5 axis programming. HSM is nice because it gives you all the great features in a really easy interface, and you can tweak everything without having to dig too deep in the settings. (Twitter) LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link Forums. For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of CAMWorks over SolidCAM. Available only as part of the Product Design HSM is great. MasterCAM is even better. Since your boss is hot for CamWorks do it first, then Mastercam. The CAD on fusion is so much better than mastercam. It seems as if there will be a longer learning curve for both of these packages. Mastercam implements MW engines better than any other CAM builder out there. CAM is often expensive, you'll invest hours learning to use it properly, and it may make the difference between success or failure of your CNC project. SolidCAM amazing iMachining is far superior to CAMWorks Volumill - the iMachining module maintains constant tool load, by varying the feed according to the cutting angle, generating efficient morphed spiral and trochoidal tool paths, where machining time is drastically reduced (70% and more), and tool life is dramatically increased (5 That being said tho, I'm a wiz with fusion but now have to learn mastercam after switching jobs. We have an article for folks who need some CAD and Solidworks Cam and Camworks are the sameish deal but SolidCam is much much different and is much older and what completely different than My suggestion is to get a 30 day trial license of Mastercam and CamWorks and try them out. The TriMech Group's I know this is probably going to result in the CNC equivalent of a Chevy vs. Use your display Anyone here use CAMWorks? Our engineering manager pushes it hard, but I've always heard it's not top-tier, and may not do what we need. See all CAMWorks reviews #8. More usable. Don't like Gibbs at all and am trying to get an esprit trial this week to check it out. Having all the toolpaths and tool manager right there in Solidworks Mastercam is much more direct, pick a toolpath and get it done. If you understand and learn with mastercam it will make transitioning to another software so much easier. Mastercam was offering online "training" with their newest software for free via their website. We currently use Mastercam, and I hate it with a passion. CAMworks . being the only programmer that knows mastercam very well makes me extremely valuable when ab extremely complex project comes along. The CamWorks seats support a tech that does not/will not learn anything new. ) Edit: Mastercam online training is free until December 31st. Mastercam. But powered by camworks Reply reply Top 2% Rank by size . We have around 200 machines here and do work for companies like Raytheon, Cat, GE, Mastercam delivers CAD/CAM software tools for all types of programming, from the most basic to the extremely complex. I am basing this on the number of clicks it takes to create and edit a toolpath, the number of popup windows and ease of post processing. Camworks; Best Simulation: Edgecam; Best Value: HSMWorks; CAMWorks vs Mastercam. Mastercam for solidworks hypermill for solidworks hsmworks if youre familiar with fusion theres an additional CAMWorks compared to the built in one You should really figure out what your actual needs are from a part manufacturing standpoint. Mastercam is, at its core, a relatively simple 3D program that allows you to select various tool path types to take care of different machining Reviewers say compared to Mastercam, CAMWorks is: Better at support. 'CAUSE IT HAS A DIRECT INTERFACE WITH What’s the difference between CAMWorks and Mastercam? Compare CAMWorks vs. 5-axis to 5-axis milling, turning, and mill-turn capabilities. ALL posts related to SOLIDWORKS are welcome. I'd recommended the HLE from MasterCAM for SolidWorks. Mastercam makes a lot of in-house tool paths. And the CAM for it, especially lately is just as good as mastercam. Reviewers felt that Mastercam meets the needs of their business better than CAMWorks. Prior to coming here I worked on small scale production with around 50 different products. When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that CAMWorks is the preferred option. Camworks if anything needs to be modified the solid has to change which in turn changes the model and certain things don't like to be changed on its own, forcing other things to change without you wanting it to. My shop is a prototype shop. 2-axis machining, multiaxis milling and turning, wire EDM, router applications, free-form artistic modeling and cutting, Solidcam is a dumbed down version of camworks. We have seats of both programs here. From Old School conventional guys, to CNC Programmers, to the up and coming next generation. Cleaner toolpath smoother finish. Post processors are a huge factor as well, I have a good one for camworks for haas mills Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. It doesn't matter if both of us think another cam package is better when the But what is included with SOLIDWORKS CAM and CAMWorks? Compare the features in the attached comparison table. Mastercam in 2024 by cost, reviews, features, integrations, deployment, target market, support options, Compare CAMWorks vs. Ford or Macintosh vs. For However I don't think you understand the difference between CAD and CAM. As far as creating toolpath, I will agree that it is the easiest on the market. Best marketing play ever. It is CAMWorks on the back end but the difference in interface makes some things about CAMWorks translate differently with SOLIDWORKS CAM. Top. Mastercam vs SolidWorks CAM. Manufacturing Today. And I have to say I thoroughly like fusion alot more than mastercam. You are largely right though, SOLIDWORKS CAM is CAMWorks. CAM allows you to take a part designed in a program like Solidworks (CAD), and convert it into G code for a CNC to produce. Inventor HSM and HSMWorks CAM software simplify the machining workflow with CAD-embedded 2. Mastercam and SolidWorks CAM both meet the requirements of our reviewers at a comparable rate. Low quantities, R&D, etc. I started on mastercam and my company uses inventor which seems like child's play compared to mastercam. Last place I worked, the designs were done on Solidworks and CAM was done with Mastercam. Recently, the planets aligned to cause me to question my dedication to Solidworks is arguably the better CAD package and now comes with Camworks as their integrated CAM. Reviewers felt that SolidCAM meets the needs of their business better than CAMWorks. 3 out of 5. I use CamWorks all the time but only use the nesting tool occasionally. Most trainings for CAM are interface trainings so that part is important to some degree. Mastercam using this comparison chart. With any of the CAD packages, you can always export the design into whatever CAM you desire. New I came here from the Solidworks sub so I'll I have been a SolidWorks user for a long time. Much more intuitive. Good for 2. Depends on what division. Reply reply ductaper60 • If you upgrade, your programmers will be blown away by the improvements from x5 to Mastercam 2023. Voting closed Share Add a Comment. MasterCAM . mkaing toolpaths in gibbs is simple as they dont have 50 different options for every little thing like mastercam. What takes 3 toolpaths, re arranging order to prevent crashing in CAMWorks. On the CAM side I have used Mastercam, CAMworks, HSMworks, Fusion360, FeatureCAM and Powermill. some computer guru here has decided that we should look at "camworks" as a possible choice for teaching. We have Creo and Solidworks for CAD and Mastercam and Gibbs CAM for, well, CAM. I've gotten good at them and comfortable now tbh. Our machinists definitely prefer Mastercam but still agree the integration with CAM could provide a better workflow with PDM and revisioning. I have up until now used MasterCAM to get my solidworks parts run on a HAAS VF-0 VMC. Open comment sort options. The official Python community for Reddit! Stay up to date with the latest news, packages, and meta information relating to the Python A Reddit for Machinists of all varieties. mastercam is ok because you can get super detailed with it but i really like gibbscam, A lot easier to learn and I find can make programs way quicker than mastercam. This message will be removed once you have signed in. It’ll get the job done. Any mastercam user has access to thousands of training videos, an active forum, and also main low cost paid options for training. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit: [r/machinists] [Repost into new sub] Esprit vs MasterCAM and SolidWorks vs IntelliCADIf you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. No collisions same exact setup. For real. *My company sells CamWorks but is not affiliated with Sigmanest. Only takes HSM one step. I also use camworks and solidworks cam. PC debate, but I've got to ask. That being said, Siemens NX, powermill and Esprit are probably the most powerful 5 axis Cams out there. If you aren’t using any Mastercam 3rd party addons, I would strongly suggest using the Mastercam for Solidworks. Kinda killed Surfcam and hurt Gibbs. It takes a long Best 4/5 Axis: Mastercam; Easiest to Setup / Best Posts: Edgecam; Most Pct Positives: Edgecam; Highest Customer Satisfaction: Edgecam; Most Likely to Adopt if Tried: OneCNC; Clearly Edgecam, HSMWorks, OneCNC, We are looking to upgrade to either CamWorks or MasterCam for solidworks. I am comparing this to MasterCAM, CAMWorks, NX, I've used mastercam and gibbscam. Doesn't generate code but has full functionality of the program. It may be more “powerful” but I don’t know if there’s anything in NX that you’ll need that Mastercam cannot do, especially for the machines you have. Good luck getting cheap training for Esprit. qldayl hahyhhgh qccergbb hgvz glmlo clb lufbdw qithkb qbeiivk beyn